"We cannot live alone" ~FDR~

International News

~Sun Tzu ~"Subdue the enemy without fighting"

Haza & Inna bellow "Objection habeas corpus, Honor admissible evidence!" toward U.S. Census in Courts..  

The Constitutional and Statutory Imperative for Categorical Separation: A Proposal for Middle Eastern and North African Racial Classification and the Protection of Religious Autonomy

  The administrative architecture of the United States government is undergoing a fundamental transformation regarding the classification of identity, a shift necessitated by decades of constitutional tension and demographic erasure. For over a century, the federal government categorized individuals of Middle Eastern and North African (MENA) descent as "White," a classification that emerged not from a shared social reality with European-descended populations, but from strategic legal battles fought in the early 20th century to circumvent exclusionary immigration laws. This proposal argues that the recent establishment of a distinct MENA category by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) is a critical step in separating racial discrimination from religious discrimination, a distinction that is essential for protecting the constitutional rights of those belonging to Eastern civilizations. By failing to distinguish between these two forms of bias, the state has historically allowed for the "racialization" of religion, where individuals are targeted based on perceived heritage regardless of their actual faith or secularism. Furthermore, this report posits that the Census Bureau must be held accountable for the accurate enumeration of these communities to prevent the dilution of political representation and the misallocation of resources, which constitutes a civil rights violation. At the corporate level, state laws—particularly those in Florida—must be rigorously applied to prevent discrimination on job applications where ancestry or heritage is used as a proxy for exclusion. Finally, this proposal warns that mandates requiring the disclosure of ancestry dating back three generations violate the First Amendment, as they infringe upon the civil liberties of the individual to self-identify and practice independent religions within the private household, free from state-sponsored genealogical determinism or corporate "sanctions".   


 

#StandUpToJewishHate

The Blue Square represented the American Jewish community, about 2% of the U.S. population, and highlighted the fact that they are the victims of a majority of all religious hate crimes in the United States, 69% as of 2024. The Blue Square has evolved to be the universal symbol of unity in the fight against Jewish hate and all hate.  

Spektor, Moore, Erez, "Heritage & Modern are the same." 

"Jewish is a culture a lifestyle, all creeds, race, gender, I shouldn't be slavery, persecution, career loss, homeless, Yemenite continues added lists of discrimination amongst Jewish diaspora.  

The Historical Construction of MENA Identity and the Paradox of Legal Whiteness

The journey of MENA Americans within the American legal system began with a fight for visibility that ultimately resulted in a different form of invisibility. Under the Naturalization Act of 1870, eligibility for citizenship was restricted to "free white persons" and "persons of African nativity and descent". This binary system left early immigrants from the Ottoman Empire, the Levant, and North Africa in a legal vacuum. Early Arab immigrants, often categorized as "Asian" by census takers, found themselves barred from citizenship by laws like the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. In response, these communities pooled their resources to litigate for their "whiteness." The landmark 1915 ruling in Dow v. United States granted Levantine Arabs legal status as white, a status that was solidified for the entire MENA region by a district court in 1944.

However, this legal whiteness was a "band-aid solution" to the more insidious problem of government-sanctioned exclusion. While it provided a pathway to citizenship, it effectively erased MENA populations from the federal data used to protect civil rights. Because they were counted as "White," any specific disparities in health, housing, or employment faced by MENA communities remained hidden within the majority population's statistics. This administrative erasure created a paradox: MENA individuals were "invisible" to the government when they sought assistance or protection, but they were "hypervisible" to law enforcement and the public as a racialized minority, particularly during times of geopolitical conflict.

The Evolution of Federal Classification Standards

The Office of Management and Budget’s Statistical Policy Directive No. 15 (SPD 15) has served as the standard for federal data on race and ethnicity since 1977.3 For decades, the definition of "White" explicitly included persons having origins in any of the original peoples of the Middle East or North Africa. It was not until the March 28, 2024 update that the OMB finally recognized the inadequacy of this categorization.

Evolution of SPD 15 

Classification for MENA Populations   Standard Year    Classification Status      Primary Impact

Initial SPD15                1977     Subsumed under "White"  Established the long-term administrative invisibility of MENA groups.

Revised Standards       1997     Subsumed under "White"  Continued to prioritize a broad "European/MENA" binary despite advocacy.

2020 Census Testing   2020    Write-in under "White" Attempted to capture detail through examples like "Lebanese" or "Egyptian".

Updated SPD 15

2024

Distinct Minimum Category

Grants co-equal status as a primary racial/ethnic category. The 2024 standards require all federal agencies to treat MENA as a "co-equal minimum category," meaning it is no longer an ethnicity to be checked after a race, but a primary identity that can be selected alongside or instead of other racial groups. This change is not merely a matter of bookkeeping; it is a constitutional imperative to ensure that the unique racialization and discrimination faced by these communities can be documented and addressed.

Peace shifts in Middle East

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nulla euismod condimentum felis vitae efficitur. Sed vel dictum quam, at blandit leo.

©Copyright. All rights reserved.

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.